Rewards for Commenting


photo credit: Photo-Mojo

One of the things I find most rewarding about blogging is the “feedback loop” it creates between writer and reader.

There’s a sense of excitement and anticipation that I get from crafting a new blog post, publishing it to the world, and sitting back and waiting for feedback.

Since this “feedback loop” is one of the primary reasons this blog exists, I’ve tried to make it easy and rewarding to leave comments.

While most of these rewards may be irrelevant to the casual reader, any blogger or website owner who’s interested in increasing their search engine rankings, readership, or online reputation will benefit from the following:

  • I’ll link to your latest blog post
  • I’ll help you make your backlink keyword-rich
  • I’ll give you a “nofollow-free” link
  • I’ll reward top commentors
  • I’ll show the world your Gravatar

I’ll link to your latest blog post

Using the awesome “Comment Luv” plugin, I’ll try to automatically add a link to your latest blog post below your comment.

Using Stephen Cronin’s “Keyword Luv” plugin, I’ll separate your name from your site name / keywords, giving you a better quality backlink. This one can be tricky to explain.. let’s just say that a link like this “David from Kiwification says…” is more valuable than a link like this “David says…“.

See? If you’re interested in building up backlinks to your blog, you don’t care about your name being hyperlinked as much as you care about your site / keywords. It’s better Google-karma, baby!

To use KeywordLuv, if your name is “The Doctor”, and your keywords are “Travel through time and space”, enter your name like this : “TheDoctor@TravelThroughTimeAndSpace”. Enter your URL as normal.

After you’ve commented three times, links in your comments to your name and URL are “no-follow free”. This “clean link” means that when Google indexes my blog, and finds a link to your site, it will be counted as a “backlink”, and factored into your PageRank score.

I’ll reward top commentors

My sidebar contains a “Top Commentors” list, which is refreshed every week. The week’s top commentors receive a backlink to their site from every page on this blog.
(image clipped from neatorama.com)

I’ll show the world your gravatar

A gravatar is a unique avatar image displayed beside your name when you comment on gravatar-enabled blogs. It makes an ordinary page of text look more like a conversation, and establishes your “personal brand”.

Sign up for a gravatar to have own your image displayed alongside your comments, on this blog and all other gravatar-enabled blogs.
(image clipped from wordpress.com)

Your comments? :)

Link Summary

  • http://www.fiddyp.co….luv-wordpress-plugin/
  • http://www.scratch99.com/
  • http://www.scratch99….ss-plugin-keywordluv/
  • http://nonofollow.net/
  • http://randaclay.com/blog/i-follow/
  • http://www.neatorama….ramas-top-commenters/
  • http://en.gravatar.com/site/signup
  • http://wordpress.com/…avatars-in-dashboard/

13 Responses to “Rewards for Commenting”

  1. Takeabreak
    Apr 7th, 2008 at 12:38 pm

    I’d like a gravatar but the link does not work.

  2. David Young
    Apr 7th, 2008 at 12:50 pm

    Oops, thanks for that.. I’ve corrected the link :)

  3. dunx
    Apr 8th, 2008 at 3:24 am

    Well, I will also implement all the lovely on SmartyPants. I am learning a lot from you, Young David!

  4. dunx
    Apr 8th, 2008 at 3:25 am

    Something got lost there. I mean all the lovely REWARDS FOR COMMENTING!….

  5. dunx
    Apr 8th, 2008 at 3:35 am

    I look like I’m spamming but now I realise you have my wrong blog address. IMPORTANT, not so? And this is NOT a ploy to get 3 quick comments.

  6. dunx
    Apr 8th, 2008 at 8:18 pm

    go to http://www.smartcraft.biz and see the cool little banner that I have found on FeedBurner. I see that your commentluv plugin isn’t very reliable. But now I have my own gravatar at least!

  7. Takeabreak
    Apr 9th, 2008 at 9:39 am

    Hey dunx, all that spamming as dethroned me as top commenter!!

  8. Takeabreak
    Apr 9th, 2008 at 9:55 am

    Well there we go! a nice new Avatar! – Cool!

  9. David Young
    Apr 9th, 2008 at 10:12 am

    Dunx – CommentLuv works for “real” blog engines like Wordpress :P

    You need a “link rel” in your metadata to your RSS feed.. here’s how to do it with thingamablog:

    http://thingamablog.sourceforg…..ee96345a4d

  10. David Young
    Apr 10th, 2008 at 4:47 pm

    I’ve added support for Stephen Cronin’s “KeywordLuv” plugin. Now you can create keyword-rich backlinks, instead of having your name backlinked to your URL.

  11. Annie from Homes For Sale in Gatlinburg TN
    May 15th, 2008 at 3:31 am

    The keywordluv plugin is great. I thought that the commentluv was a beautiful thing, but this takes the cake. kudos to Stephen Cronin. I suspect that as more of these kinds of plugins come out the better the spam blocking software will need to be. It should definitely help with comments though. Nice post.

  12. Markus Baumann from New Zealand wilderness photos
    May 17th, 2008 at 6:54 pm

    Thank you for this post David, putting me onto CommentLuv and KeywordLuv. Will implement them on my blog too.

  13. Bob from Tampa Bay Subdivisions
    May 31st, 2008 at 7:12 am

    Hey thanks for all the opportunities here. I have been able to switch my blog to nofollow and I have created the gravatar. I tried to install the keywordluv on my blog yesterday but ran into serious problems. Wiil try again, I would like to offer my commenters anchor text as well.

2 responses to “Rewards for Commenting”

  1. The Great New Zealand Dave Shave ‘08

    [...] Rewards for Commenting [...]

  2. 8 Twitter-ers to follow in New Zealand

    [...] Rewards for Commenting [...]